The opinions posted on the Pagan Perspective pages are those of individuals and are not neccessarily shared or endorsed by the Witches' Voice inc.
Posted: Sep. 8, 2002
||This Page Viewed: 14,081,309
Vox Q Stats|
Times Viewed: 32,767
Lurker/Post Ratio: 399 to 1
Question of the Week: 10 - 10/9/2000
Money and the Craft
Money And The Craft is something that Pagans have wrestled with for decades. Are tarot readings and the like really a "part of the Wiccan religion"? Should we consider a "paid clergy"? What do YOU think about exchanging teaching, readings or clergy service for cash?
| Reponses: There are 82 responses posted to this question.
|| Reverse Sort
| I Think That Tarot And The Like Are Part Of The Pagan... ||Oct 12th. at 2:27:58 pm UTC|
|Katherine netherwood (Leeds) ||Age: 14 - Email |
I think that tarot and the like are part of the pagan thoughts and love for the mother, But exchanging them for cash is an insult to the mother and we who do our own readings and palmstry. J ust a note a very good day this month Friday 13th and its a full moon too.
Thankyou and Blessed be
Jhessail of the coven of the Nymph.
| A Paid Clergy Wouldn't Be A Solution For Wicca; We're All Priests... ||Oct 12th. at 4:28:41 pm UTC|
|Nwyvre (Zwijndrecht, Netherlands) ||Age: 17 - Email |
A paid clergy wouldn't be a solution for WICCA; we're all priests and priestesses, so we should all have to be paid... However, I do think that paying other people for their services is possible. There are, for example, people who devote their spare time to giving workshops or readings. I think it is no more than reasonable to pay those people for their services, just as we pay pagan writers for their books or pagan craftsmen for their artifacts. But it is not a good thing to pay other pagans for all they do. Healing work, for instance, or casting a spell for someone else's benefit, are activities that should not be charged. Otherwise there'll be more and more people, pretending they are powerful magicians or whatever, and wanting to be paid for what they do. A famous trick is to tell someone he/she is cursed and then wanting to be paid to remove the curse.
All in all, I think the most important thing is to remember that if people offer us services we ask, if they teach us or if they do readings, it's no more than reasonable to pay them for it (especially if it's the only thing they do for money). But if someone wants to force you to pay or makes you use his/her services, then don't pay. We don't want charlatans around, do we?
| I Think That Offering People The Benefit Of Our Religious Insights For... ||Oct 12th. at 6:18:55 pm UTC|
|Anfa (Vancouver, British Columbia CA) ||Age: 29 - Email |
I think that offering people the benefit of our religious insights for money smacks of the old Catholic practice of selling "indulgences." Yes, we don't claim to sell absolution but I can no more picture myself charging for my insights than I can selling my prayers. The goddess has gifted me with my knowledge of her and my ability to see beyond the tangible and I would not sell anything given to me out of love.
As to whether tarot cards and the like are actually "part of the Wiccan religion" I think that they are truly not but that they are such common tools used by the people of the Wiccan faiths that they have become almost inseparable from us. Think of the Fish or the Cross and Christianity. Are fish Christian or are they simply a symbol? Is a Cross on a chain really a religious relic or something so commonly associated with a particular religion that it takes on some of the power and mystery of the religion itself? Tarot and other divination tools are often viewed as Wiccan "signature" items...they are how others define us, not necessarily how we define ourselves.
| I Don't Feel That Tarot Or Divination Is Neccesarily A "part Of... ||Oct 12th. at 11:45:14 pm UTC|
|Maythen Apple (Redding, California US) ||Age: 23 - Email |
I don't feel that tarot or divination is neccesarily a "part of the Wiccan religion". It is a tool used by more than one spiritual path. While I've met many tarot readers, not all were wiccan. If you take away my cards it wont make me anyless a witch.
on the whole idea of paid clergy:
I must say it makes me reluctant whenever I hear the cry of "Pay Me Pay Me". Perhaps it comes from bad experiences with other religions. It takes a lot of time and work to be clergy, I don't want to deny that. I can understand everyone pitching in to pay for supplies, space rental, and other expenses. But beyond that makes me a trifle skittish.
| If This Is Your Profession As Well As Religion Then Why Not... ||Oct 13th. at 3:58:20 am UTC|
|Osiris (New Orleans, Louisiana US) ||Age: 24 |
If this is your profession as well as religion then why not be compensated for it? Everyone needs to earn money in some form...so long as it is legal and it harms none!
| I For One Think This Is Crazy. To Accept Money For Our... ||Oct 13th. at 11:44:11 am UTC|
|Pat Harrington (Chicago, Illinois US) ||Age: 26 - Email |
I for one think this is crazy. To accept money for our knowledge of the craft be littles how special it really is. We would go back to the days when witches used to hide there knowledge. I think one of the best part about being a "witch" is that there is so much support out there. So many other witches are more that willing to lend you a hand to help you find your way. I personaly think that obtaining money for helping would only lead to us recruiting outsiders. Which I feel is what really sets us apart from other religions. On AOL I chat in a room called "ask a witch, " and from time to time this can be a strain trying to tell somebody the same thing over and over can be hard. But I enjoy it, cause I am not only helping to educate outsiders to what we really are, but are also helping my fellow pagan in times of need. I think we are doing a great job with helping each other out, never have I felt so much love from my fellow man/woman then I do now. Thanks. =)
| In My Opinion. I Personally Think It Is A Matter Of Preference... ||Oct 13th. at 12:23:57 pm UTC|
|Artemis CrystalMoon (Baylis, Illinois US) ||Age: 20 - Email |
In my opinion.
I personally think it is a matter of preference. I do Tarot readings for members of my family and some of my friends. I have never asked for payment and they have never offered. I am still learning to do readings for myself, but sometimes I go to a friend of mine when I need a reading done that I feel I cannot read properly. When I go to her, I bring a gift in exchange. The last time she did a reading for me, I gave her a cucumber-melon scented bar of soap. For me, I like to trade and barter with other Pagans. But I think that it is up to the person doing the reading to decide if they want payment or not.
| I Have No Qualms About Charging For Readings Made For People Outside... ||Oct 13th. at 12:32:29 pm UTC|
|Silver MayKitten (Springfield, Missouri US) ||Age: 55 - Email |
I have no qualms about charging for readings made for people outside my family and group. After all if you give them away for free you get overloaded with reading requests from freeloaders who will not pay even a buck for a reading.
Likewise if someone asks me for healing prayers I will hand them an envelope and say that my cost is just under three dollars, please put a donation into the envelope when I leave the room and place it in the basket on the buffet. (Czech it out for your self, candles, annointing oil &c, it comes to (the last time I calculated it, ) US$ 1.81.) Usually they put a ten or twenty in the envelope, sometimes as much as a hundred; others just put an empty envelope into the basket, and some I suspect of this I know just cannot afford anything.
Incidently I only open only about half the envelopes selected at random once a month.
As to a paid clergy; it is proper I think for a HP and HPS to ask a fee for Wiccaning, handfasting, premarital councelling, family councelling, handparting, healing rites and funerals, these tie up their time and resources just as clergy of any other faith. Likewise the cleric who takes care of the federal and state paperwork of running a non-profit organization, which is what an organized coven is, deserves some kind of allowance; don't forget they often have to set aside time for those all day semenars on 501c3 and the like, and they have to take time off from work to deal with lawyers, bureaucrats other vexations.
| Some Thoughts Off The Top Of My Head... Divination, Whether By Runes... ||Oct 13th. at 12:37:07 pm UTC|
|galen wainwright (New Westminster, British Columbia CA) ||Age: 34 - Email |
Some thoughts off the top of my head...
Divination, whether by Runes, Tarot, heated oil, smoke, dreams, the flight of birds, etc., etc. has long been a part of our faith. When we employ the various methods we are only looking for a hint of things to come, asking that the gods and goddesses point one of the ways the future may turn.
As to being paid for our knowledge and craft, I agree that yes, a *modest* amount may be accepted, of if the person can return the deed in kind ie.- barter.
I have read many stories where self serving fraud artists charge hundreds, even thousands of dollars to perform a ritual they *guarantee* will work. When it doesn't, the victim tries to get their money back, only to be told a litanny of excuses for the ritual's failure. Among the most offensive are, the victim's faith in the ritual was not strong enought, they did not pay enough (and now they must pay more), or too bad, it was a one shot and you already paid for services rendered. The victim then goes to the police to lay fraud charges, but more often than not remains silent so as not to appear an even greater fool.
For the idea of a 'paid clergy'...hmmm...I can think of no good reason to have one. I know, historically, that preists and preistess' were given food and shelter but that was at a time when only they were initiated into the deeper mysteries of their faiths. To have a 'paid clergy' to me sounds like falling back on the X-tian doctrine of 'we know so little, and the man at the front knows so much more'. On that path lies gross abuse of power and influence.
Walk in peace,
| In Tarot, I Only Ask For A Trinket Or Something They've Had... ||Oct 13th. at 7:43:12 pm UTC|
|Matthew McFadden (Iowa City, Iowa US) ||Age: 23 - Email |
In Tarot, i only ask for a trinket or something they've had contact with, , when they try to offer money, i ask them if they ever have to pay to look in a mirror when they wake up in the morning.
I also tend to believe that all forms of learning/teaching should be free. we'd get alot more good done, if we weren't so worried about the money system in the first place. *not fond of money*
| I Feel Tarot Readings Are A Part Of The Wiccan "religion", Insofar... ||Oct 13th. at 10:23:21 pm UTC|
|Rev. Aurila (Monroe, Washington US) ||Age: 35 - Email |
I feel tarot readings are a part of the Wiccan "religion", insofar as it's a common tool that many of us use. As for charging a fee for readings, I see nothing wrong with that, provided the reader's motive isn't greed. I don't charge; I simply tell a client (whether friend, family, or other) that if they honestly feel I've helped them, they can leave a donation or drop a barter item off later. I've received gift certificates for restaurants and stores, a pre-paid phone card for my cellphone, and homemade goodies.
As for "paid clergy", each of us is a member of the clergy. I personally am an ordained minister, since it seems to reassure some non-Pagans that my faith is a valid one (I know...Sounds egotistical, but it does help to breach some people's resistence to anything non-Christian!). There is nothing wrong about being compensated for services rendered, as long as you don't let the money make decisions for you.
| Personally, I Think That It Is Wrong To Charge For Such Sevices... ||Oct 14th. at 1:20:21 am UTC|
|Soloswan (Malvern, Arkansas US) ||Age: 36 - Email |
Personally, I think that it is wrong to charge for such sevices. It takes away from the true need of things so to speak. But, if someone wants to give you something in exchange for a reading or help (spells ect...) be it money or a service of their own, that is wonderful.
Web Site Content (including: text - graphics - html - look & feel)
Copyright 1997-2017 The Witches' Voice Inc. All rights reserved
Note: Authors & Artists retain the copyright for their work(s) on this website.
Unauthorized reproduction without prior permission is a violation of copyright laws.
Website structure, evolution and php coding by Fritz Jung on a Macintosh G5.
Any and all personal political opinions expressed in the public listing sections (including, but not restricted to, personals, events, groups, shops, Wrenâ€™s Nest, etc.) are solely those of the author(s) and do not reflect the opinion of The Witchesâ€™ Voice, Inc. TWV is a nonprofit, nonpartisan educational organization.
Sponsorship: Visit the Witches' Voice Sponsor Page for info on how you
can help support this Community Resource. Donations ARE Tax Deductible.
The Witches' Voice carries a 501(c)(3) certificate and a Federal Tax ID.
Mail Us: The Witches' Voice Inc., P.O. Box 341018, Tampa, Florida 33694-1018 U.S.A.