The opinions posted on the Pagan Perspective pages are those of individuals and are not neccessarily shared or endorsed by the Witches' Voice inc.
Posted: Sep. 8, 2002
||This Page Viewed: 9,250,468
Vox Q Stats|
Times Viewed: 32,767
Lurker/Post Ratio: 300 to 1
Question of the Week: 83 - 10/27/2002
Time to Talk Politics and Elections…
Eek! It’s the silly season again.
For U.S. Pagans/Heathens: The U.S. is holding mid-term elections Nov. 5th. Will you be voting? What are the issues that are most important to you? Do you vote by issue or by party? Do you have any thoughts on how it will turn out?
Non-U.S. Pagans/Heathens: The U.S. is woefully ignorant about your political processes. Please enlighten us. How many parties do you have? What are the names of the parties and what platforms do they represent? Do you have 'liberals' and 'conservatives'? How often do you vote? Do you elect representatives? How do you contact these representatives about your issues?
As always while talking politics, discussions can become heated. Please stay on the issues and do not resort to personal attacks. Further discussions should be taken to e-mail.
| Reponses: There are 109 responses posted to this question.
|| Reverse Sort
| As Far As The Second Amewndment Goes ||Nov 6th. at 6:36:01 pm UTC|
|Aedh Rua (New Richmond, WI) ||Age: 36 - Email |
I'm all for it, actually. I am not in the least anti-gun. The higher American murder rates simply reflect a difference in culture, and would happen regardless of what gun-control stautes were on the books. If the Columbine kids hadn't had guns to use, they would have used gasoline and Tide detergent.
As far as the Second Amendment is concerned, the Republicans are closer to what I believe. But so what? They are absolutely eager to eliminate all the others.
Look at it this way: a Canadian, a British subject, or an Australian can write his or her MP,and otherwise organize to get gun rights back. In America, you will have your guns, but on the day you leave them at home, the secret police will drag you off to a torture chamber. And, already, you would not be able to legally say anything about it. Right now, according to the USA-PATRIOT Act, if the FBI ask questions of a librarian about what someone has checked out, the librarian may not legally tell anyone the FBI were there. To call the American Library Association is a federal offence. I am not making this up; I got it from the Wisconsin Library Association.
Do guns help keep tyranny at bay? Sure they do, but they can't stop it by themselves. And they really can't stop it when the populace as a whole supports the tyrant, as they do in America.
That last is really why I want to leave this country. I doubt that I will be arrested anytime soon. But I just don't like living in a country where the population as a whole has values so utterly alien to my own.
| Why, Why, Why, Anneka? To The Tune Of Tom Jones "Delilah"... ||Nov 6th. at 7:35:34 pm UTC|
|Irusan (Bastrop,TX) ||Age: 53 - Email |
Anneka, you say that guns are your hobby and that I should not criticize you for it. Let's just say that this is my personal hangup. I am entitled to my opinion, and I hope I don't get shot for it.
Believe me, I was brought up saturated by the gun culture. I know about people who are into the scene. I just don't understand it. Could you please explain to me why firearms are so attractive to you? Does it help you deal with fears, or do you enjoy being feared? Is it a warm memory association of being with your parents, shooting things? Do you like the loud noise? What is it?
As to the poster who said that gun violence is OK because it is just a difference in culture, that the Columbine murders would have taken place without guns, are you saying that murder is a quaint fixation of Americans, the way Japanese like taking photos and talking cameras?
| Wait A Minute ||Nov 6th. at 8:06:15 pm UTC|
|Aedh Rua UiMhorrigu (New Richmond, WI) ||Age: 36 - Email |
I never said that gun violence was ok. But violence IS a part of American culture, and has been for centuries. Americans don't just lead the Western world in gun violence, but in all types of crime. This is not a quaint custom, nor is it OK, nor a good thing in any sense. But, it is nothing that gun control will change. For that matter, I doubt that anything can change it at all, except maybe methods far more horrific than the problem they "solve", and maybe even they wouldn't work.
Americans don't have a gun culture, they have a violence culture. Despite this, America has done many great things in the world, and was at one time the hope of the Earth. Now, the darkest impulses of the American psyche have completely overcome "what Lincoln called 'the better angels of our nature'".
The Second Amendment is important to me. But, the British, the Irish, the Canadians, the Australians, and many other peoples are free and democratic without it. I will take my chances in a country which may have gun control, but which still respects liberty, and which also supports compassion, the environment, international law, and a civil society, all things which America has now rejected.
| What's The First Thing The Republicans Will Do Now? ||Nov 6th. at 8:39:32 pm UTC|
|Irusan (Bastrop,TX) ||Age: 53 - Email |
Can you say ANWR, boys and girls?
(My last post for tonight)
| Excuse Me? Violence Is American Culture? ||Nov 6th. at 8:53:38 pm UTC|
|Stephanie (New Orleans) ||Age: 47 - Email |
My first reaction is "No, violence is part of Western European Culture that was brought to America". Consider the nature of the beast in Ireland between the Protestants and the Catholics, then I think, "No, consider the violent nature of the Muslim men in the Arab states and elsewhere", and then I think "No, consider the violent nature of the Chinese toward the Tibetans and other Orientals". Then I think "NO, violence seems to just be part of patriarchal civilization PERIOD". Yes, we are definitely more violent in the USA, I also think we're more spoiled and bored in the USA, and also more apathetic because as a whole, we don't appreciate the freedoms that we do have here...we take them for granted. Evidence of that is that only a little more than 39% of the voting age population voted, (and that was high). So I don't consider this election or any election "the mindset of the American People". It is the of the slim majority that voted. One thing we have to realize is that the Christian Reich definitely has organized over the last 2 decades and has it's sheeple voting in lock-step. They don't even question...they vote for who they are told to vote for according to religious lines and anti-choice lines. When the Pagan Unity Campaign attempted to put together a brief statement as to what W/P/W's were for the press and the politicians to understand that we have the capability of being a voting block, all hell broke loose over that "definition". How pathetic. On another note, we all need to remember that the last Congressional race put the Republicans in control of the Senate for one day. Then one Republican Senator switched to Independent. I am not a Republican and I'm not a Democrat. I vote for people, issues, etc, regardless of party. Not all Republicans are of the Religious Reich, I know as I used to be one. The moderates are out there. If one man switched to Independent last time out of fear of the havoc that could be wrought with a same party House and Senate, it can happen again. There may be more than a few Republican Senators that see the danger of a House, Senate And White House single party. Who knows what the next few days can bring. If I remember correctly a Rhode Island Republican Senator has been iffy for a few weeks. I for one, will keep my wits about me, not give in, not give up hope and fight till my dying breath to keep the Constitution intact.
| Oh, Irusan ||Nov 6th. at 10:21:33 pm UTC|
|Anneka (Nevada, USA) ||Age: 24 - Email |
You know, I really like you. I can't help it. You mentioned Tom Jones. You must be at least sort of ok! (I know, I know, I'm a freak.)
Why do I like to shoot? Well, it's complicated, but let me explain.
My father taught me to shoot (along with 3 of my brothers) when I was 8 years old. We didn't spend a lot of time together, he and I, so partially it IS fond memories. But wait, there's more! In school, one of the only sports I did well (I'm a major klutz) was archery. I may not be able to spike a volleyball, but give me a bow and arrow, and I'm fairly competent. I like darts, too. Then, when I met my husband, we started going shooting together (there's a lovely indoor range about 15 minutes from us.) It's a way for us to hang out together, while relieving stress and practicing something I'm pretty good at. I also want to make sure, that if it ever did (and it hasn't yet) come down to defending myself and my family, I can comfortably fire a weapon and be pretty damn sure of hitting my target. It's not a fear thing at all. Just a precaution. And I have no reason to make people want to fear me. No one needs to fear me, unless they attack me or my family. I'm actually a pretty nice person, mostly. (I do, however, tend to bite. Kindergarten habits die hard!) Remember, shooting is also a sport, and a much less violent sport than hockey. And I hunt occasionally, because I get really tired of irradiated, processed, handled by 20 million people meat. For everyone who will be angry with me for hunting, let me say I do NOT agree with "closed hunts" or anything where the animals are penned. I hardly agree with hunting with rifles. I think the animals deserve a chance, and every time I see on TV some "hunter" trying to kill an animal in a pen, and the animal attacks the hunter, I laugh my head off.
So I'm not a "gun freak" per se. I'm a failry reasonable, young, educated, stable American Woman, who happens to enjoy a very popular pasttime.
| Uh, Stephanie........ ||Nov 7th. at 12:33:06 am UTC|
|Aedh Rua UiMhorrigu (New Rchmond, WI) ||Age: 36 - Email |
I said that violence is A PART of American culture, and that this has much to do with American crime rates and rates of violent death. This is just a truism. Is violence part of other Western cultures? Sure, but they express it differently, at least today. In this case, the different crime rates, rather less pronounced than in the past, but still very clear, speak for themselves.
In any case, this has very little, or maybe nothing, to do with why I want to leave America. American violence doesn't bother me. It is, if anything, familiar, honest, and reminiscent of the culture of those ancient Celts and Norsemen we supposedly revere. What bothers me is the increasingly fundamentalist tone of American life, the bigoted rejection of other cultures, mostly my own, the corruption and dishonesty which permeates every aspect of existence in most parts of America today, and the general incivility with which we all deal on a daily basis.
In the last town I lived in, in rural Illinois, I was the library director. At my library, I was the only person there who believed in evolution. The only one! Everyone else there was a creationist. Most of the people of that community also believed that Black people should not be allowed to live in their town, that the death penalty should be applied swiftly, so that there would be no time for DNA testing, that murdering "abortionists" was a good idea, and similar monstrous things. I had one guy tell me that "killing all the fags" was a good idea. There were lectures for law enforcement and the general public on how to recognize "Satanic cults", which meant Pagans, really. I attended this lecture, so I know. The lecturer was very clear that Wicca=Satanism, using many of the arguments Kerr Cuchulainn talks about. Despite their Christian beliefs, these people held honor, compassion, honesty, kindness, loyalty, and intelligence in utter contempt. They cheated each other, hated their neighbors, stole when they could, and abused their children, all the while talking about "good family values", or "good (insert town here) people".
To be sure, there were decent people there, but those people were tiny sparks of light in great and hideous darkness. They thought they were helping the people of this town, but all they were really doing was enabling them, making it easier for them to live as they did.
Things are much better where I live now, but this is only one town of many, and even here I would not be comfortable being open about my religion. As much as I would like to believe that most of the country are like the Twin Cities and Western Wisconsin, my own travels and the elections of the last two decades tell me this isn't so. Rather, rural Illinois, and rural Ohio, the Bible Belt shitholes, represent the real America, the real American soul of today.
You can talk about the number of people who don't vote, but I suspect that we are lucky they don't, because otherwise we might be in camps already. I see no evidence that there are large numbers of liberal voters out there waiting for someone to organize them, and much evidence that the vast majority of the American people who don't vote are as vile as most of the ones I knew in Illinois.
Under these circumstances, the only really viable option for Pagans is to retreat to a more supportive country, regroup there, and organize ourselves as a community, while reaching out to our new hosts. In time, if we play our cards right, we will be an accepted part of our new country. If our new country is in Europe, then we can play a role in the coming superpower conflict between the United States and Europe. Make no mistake, that conflict is coming. The values of the average Americans I knew in Illinois are so malignant, and so diametrically opposed to the values of the average European, that some kind of hostility is inevitable.
In time, the values of the new America will cause its decline, as surely as night follows day. America today is still the mightiest nation on Earth, but in time its strength will dwindle, and that of Europe will grow. Iniquity cannot stand forever, and the very land revolts against the unjust. So, in time, America will be what the former Soviet Union is today -- the dried out husk of a nation. Then perhaps we, or, more likely, our great-grandchildren, can return and reclaim our native land, if it is indeed worth reclaiming.
So, if you think I am a coward leaving this country out of fear, think again. I am leaving out of disgust, quite aware that my standard of living will probably decline, but unwilling to be ashamed of my country any longer.
| Europe ||Nov 7th. at 12:57:12 am UTC|
|Calixto (Richmond VA) ||Age: 30 - Email |
If you think Europe is necessaily accepting of us, you might have a shock coming.
In France certain religico-magickal orders have been *banned* (such as the OTO). In France and Germany, bureaucrats and politicians have the power to restrict or limit religions based on whether they consider it a "cult" (and they have broad discretion in making this decision). In England, Norway, Sweden, and other places there is a State Church, usually with low attendance...and its no longer common to discriminate against non-members...though the old laws may be on the books in places.
If you wish to go, good luck. My personal preference is not for the socio-economic or even political system (proportional representation), so its not a necessarily preferable place for several reasons. Nor do I relish the idea of going somewhere where my religious order is banned. :(
| Actually, I Already Know This ||Nov 7th. at 1:26:25 am UTC|
|Aedh Rua UiMhorrigu (NewRichmond, WI) ||Age: 36 - Email |
A couple of years ago, I almost gave up my job search in the United States, and started one overseas. I didn't because I knew that Europe was hardly a panacea, and that I thought that there were decent parts of the United States. And so there are, but these areas are tiny island in a vast wasteland.
The French law is a reason why France might be less than desirable as a destination. The German law, I am told by people who live there, is not applied against Pagans groups. If this information should prove wrong, and there is plenty of time to find out, then I would cross Germany off the list. The Scandinavian countries do have state churches, and Denmark recently refused to give state money to Asatru groups. However, this underscores the fact that the Asatru were able to ask. In Britain, Paganism is growing even more rapidly than in the United States. As in America, there are isolated incidents of local persecution, but those are suaully followed by apologies, and often by public indignation against the persecutors. In other incidents, Pagans are getting recognition in such areas as participation in determining the use
of megalithic monuments.
In any case, European countries are only a few of several possible destinations. There must be some country which we can support. I refuse to accept that the best I can hope for is a choice between always looking over my shoulder, or being open about my religion, and therefore living in the ghetto.
It should be noted that all any of the people who have told me to stay can come up with is either "you coward", or "things are even worse somewhere else". That isn't good enough. No one has yet been able to say that Pagans are really safe in the United States, or that there is any realistic chance of the United States ever again devleoping a culture I can respect. All a negative appraoch does is to convince me that not only America, but indeed the world is a wasteland, and that there is very little reason to live, in ANY country.
Somehow I doubt that is the point you are trying to make. Or is it?
| Vote! ||Nov 7th. at 1:41:39 pm UTC|
|KJD (New Hampshire) ||Age: 23 - Email |
This Pagan voted Republican! I register as 'undecided' because
I have no problem crossing party line when I believe in what is
being said. But unofficially, I am Republican, and generally vote
| Irusan ||Nov 7th. at 1:49:18 pm UTC|
|KJD (New Hampshire) ||Age: 23 - Email |
Ease-up! Guns are not illegal. If you're not inclined to learn how to use one then fine, but no one should have to answer for themselves about being able to shoot one - whether or not they do it as a hobby or not. Now, I grew up with guns in the house and responsible parents, I don't like handeling one and I don't like shooting one...But, I know how to do it. Why? Because if I was ever to be put into a violent situation by someone and there was a gun involved, and I was able to get ahold of the gun I would know how to protect myself. So lets remember that opinions are just that... and to each their own.
| "Ease-up! Guns Are Not Illegal." ||Nov 8th. at 12:28:25 pm UTC|
|Jack Flash (Stockbridge, Mass.) ||Age: 52 - Email |
And right you are, AND 11,000 Americans were executed by 'shottin irons' last year alone (mostly domestic killings).
The Bush cartel knows you want your guns and that FOR that you will give them your vote and everything else they want. I am sure the democrats know that as well, but the republicans have you convinced that the democrats will take away your guns (not a chance).
I like the 2nd amendment too... it is there so that the people have the option to 'rise up and overthrow' a govenment if it plays to a small group of special interests and NOT to the tax payer/common wo/man.
I am real curious as to how A battle between the everyday joes/janes and their own brothers/sisters in the us military would play out. -- I would think that to stand a prayer the avg. citizens would need some serious weapons/fire power instead of just pop shooters and huntin rifles JUST be in the game. Shouldn't the common man be building up a collection of tanks, missles and stuff? otherwise isn't the whole reason for the 2nd amendment lost?
Web Site Content (including: text - graphics - html - look & feel)
Copyright 1997-2014 The Witches' Voice Inc. All rights reserved
Note: Authors & Artists retain the copyright for their work(s) on this website.
Unauthorized reproduction without prior permission is a violation of copyright laws.
Website structure, evolution and php coding by Fritz Jung on a Macintosh G5.
Any and all personal political opinions expressed in the public listing sections (including, but not restricted to, personals, events, groups, shops, Wrenâ€™s Nest, etc.) are solely those of the author(s) and do not reflect the opinion of The Witchesâ€™ Voice, Inc. TWV is a nonprofit, nonpartisan educational organization.
Sponsorship: Visit the Witches' Voice Sponsor Page for info on how you
can help support this Community Resource. Donations ARE Tax Deductible.
The Witches' Voice carries a 501(c)(3) certificate and a Federal Tax ID.
Mail Us: The Witches' Voice Inc., P.O. Box 341018, Tampa, Florida 33694-1018 U.S.A.