Articles/Essays From Pagans
May 19th. 2013 ...
The Role of Identity in Magic
Talking Trash? It's a Dirty Subject but Waste Happens.
My Wiccan Journey
13 Keys: The Victory of Netzach
May 12th. 2013 ...
Pagan Studies I: How Should We Define Modern Paganism?
Nothing Special... Part Two
The Third Path
May 5th. 2013 ...
The Value of Multicultural Awareness
Put Your Back Into It (Our Lady of the Sacred Honey Badger)
Moon Musings, Planetary Preponderances and Red Lipped Bat Fish
April 28th. 2013 ...
Lessons from the Lessers: Iris
April 21st. 2013 ...
Taken By The Goddess: The Crescent Moon Tattoo
The Gods/Being Godbothered
To Be A Witch
The Archetypes are Gods: Re-godding the Archetypes
April 14th. 2013 ...
On The Inclusion of Children
'Wand Fun' With Grandson
Lessons from a Baby
Lessons of Freedom: On Divinity and Healing
April 7th. 2013 ...
Out of the Broom Closet... Sorta
A Journey Through the Witches Tarot
History and Science Behind Numerology
March 31st. 2013 ...
What is the Magickal Self?
Ethics and Numerology
March 24th. 2013 ...
Keystones of the Sacred Land
March 17th. 2013 ...
Why Some Pagans and Witches Still Hide
Witch Heritage 101: What Happens When Witch Haters Joke about anti-Witch Films
I'm Not a Broom. So What's with the Closet?
March 10th. 2013 ...
Top Ten Stupid Things I Did as a New Pagan: Part 3
Hunting for the Real Witch in Film
The Collective Shadow
Lies - The Opposite of Truth
March 3rd. 2013 ...
Grounding and Releasing Negative Energy
A Patchwork of Magick
February 24th. 2013 ...
Top Ten Stupid Mistakes I Made as a New Pagan (Part Two)
February 17th. 2013 ...
Top Ten Stupid Mistakes I made as a New Pagan... Part One
Gardening with Crystal Energies
A Call from the Ancestors
Moon Musings, Planetary Preponderances and Black Water Snakes
February 10th. 2013 ...
We Are the Weirdos, Mister: A Completely Uncool Story of Origin
February 3rd. 2013 ...
"I'll Grind Your Bones to Make my Bread": Pagans and Animal Husbandry
The Role of Contemporary Culture in Magic
A Pagan Response to Endangered Earth
The Great Mother's Gift, Heinlein, and the Nature of Squirrels
13 Keys: The Glory of Hod
January 27th. 2013 ...
Why We Do Need Wicca
The Cosmos In the Coffee Shop
On Travel Spirituality and Magick
January 20th. 2013 ...
Beloved Backs and How to Save Them
Building or Burning Bridges?
Plants, Magic and Intuition
Plagiarism - How It Harms Our Community
January 13th. 2013 ...
Ramblings of a Pagan Guy: Stupid Clichés
The Magick and Power of Words
Aging Is Not Easy
The Riddle of Who We Are?
January 6th. 2013 ...
Wicca v Witchcraft
A Witch in the Closet
How Many People Can You Fit Under An Umbrella?
Gut Hunches, Mouse Dreams, and Pinkie Sense
December 30th. 2012 ...
Ritual "Cheat Sheet" Bracelet
Magick is All Around Us
Confessions of a Living Satyr
A Tiny Bit of Belly Dance History
December 23rd. 2012 ...
The Warrior Goddess and You.
World Change: A Message from Greece
What's the Meaning of Life, Anyway?
My Brother's Keeper
December 16th. 2012 ...
Keeping Christ in Xmas
Love is the Law
Listen to Your Heart's Wisdom
NOTE: For a complete list of articles related to this chapter... Visit the Main Index FOR this section.
Article ID: 13486
Age Group: Adult
Days Up: 1,368
Times Read: 3,324
RSS Views: 14,955
Author: Rhys Chisnall
Posted: August 23rd. 2009
Times Viewed: 3,324
Whilst on holiday recently, in the West Country, my girlfriend and I stopped off briefly in Glastonbury. I was both shocked and amazed when I discovered that one shop was selling sticks, oh sorry I mean staffs, for £135! Don’t people know you can pick these things up for free in your local woods?
What is worse, when browsing the Internet, I have seen courses in Wicca offered from £200, or more, and on closer inspection they contained the same content as your average Popular Wicca book at £15! What is going on? Is the turning of spirituality into a commodity really desirable?
We could get into a heated debate about what Wicca and the Craft really are. Certainly, from the perspective of the initiatory Craft, practitioners would agree that this commercialization of training is fundamentally wrong. However, this argument is unlikely to influence those who have a very different view of Witchcraft. It would simply end in a row about what Witchcraft is.
As such it is difficult to show, philosophically, that selling all forms of Wicca/Witchcraft is unethical or wrong, but it is possible I think to show that it denotes an undesirable trait, by looking at how we value things.
Before I go on I would say that I am not talking about people who charge a small fee to cover their expenses in training, nor am I having a go at craftsmen who put a lot of time and effort into their work and produce wonderful and beautiful artifacts that are sold at a fair price. Nor am I talking about people who charge a reasonable price for providing a service, nor is it about people who write books, most of whom write for love of their subject rather than financial reward.
My targets for this essay are those who sell over priced ‘Wicca’ stuff and Witchcraft training for profit.
The argument is simple in that I am going to assume that all who practice Witchcraft value it, it is important to them. In her essay, ‘Neither use, nor Ornamental”, the philosopher Jane Howarth talks about two kinds of valuing: “instrumental” and “non instrumental” value.
“Things with instrumental value include consumables, raw materials and literally instruments…such things serve a means to an end, they serve our purpose.” (Howarth, p.230) .
Arguably Witchcraft has an instrumental value, regardless of whether you consider it as a discipline that leads to experience of the mysteries and self-empowerment as in initiatory Craft, access to the favor of the gods in Pop Wicca, or as healing and therapy as per New Age Wicca. It serves a specific function.
People don’t tend to get to uppity when it comes to selling things with instrumental value like knives, washing machines or cars. These things are replaceable. You could in theory replace initiatory Craft with Sufism, Mystical Christianity, or the Qabbalah in order to experience the mysteries or you may replace New Age Wicca with Reiki for healing. However, somehow, where spiritual traditions are concerned that just doesn’t seem right.
“The crucial feature about non instrumental value, in contrast, is that the [thing] has value because of the specific properties it has. A change to those properties would affect, or at least require a reassessment of its value.” (Ibid. p230) .
Therefore we may value an oak tree for the particular properties it possesses. If someone was to dig up our oak and replace it with an ash, or a supermarket, we might get upset as the oak is replaced with something else.
Non-instrumental value is a value that is not replaceable. We value it not because it has some use to us, but in and of itself. I would suggest that this is true of whatever type of Witchcraft we practice.
It goes deeper than this, as Hoswarth nodding towards Heidegger’s concept of care, suggests a third way of valuing, i.e. cherishing. She argues that cherishing is not simply behavior or instrumental, but is an interaction, a relationship between two things. She claims that cherishing has three aspects.
Firstly, that what one cherishes is irreplaceable. So for Witchcraft, replacing it with something else whether it is Qabbalah or Reiki just will not do.
Secondly, we have a history of past interaction with it. In other words we have spent time, energy, hard work and discipline practicing it and presumably have gotten results.
Thirdly we take care of it. We want the best for it, and do our best when working with it.
I would argue that it is within this non-instrumental cherishing that it becomes undesirable to sell the Craft. Who amongst us would want to sell our most treasured possessions? Some things are simply beyond a price. They are just too valuable to us that we would want to use them to make money. As such if we cherish the Craft, however we practice it we would not want to sell it on to just anybody or see it turned into a mere money making commodity.
We also find it undesirable when other people sell the things we cherish. Imagine how you would feel if something you cherished was sold by someone else. Consider something sacred to you being turned into nothing more than a commodity. So it is with the Craft.
Yes we all know that what is being sold in these £200 plus courses is not the same thing that we would call Witchcraft, but somehow, because of the name being used to sell it, it feels to us that what we cherish is being turned into a commercial money making enterprise. Sadly some people know the cost of everything, but the value of nothing!!!
However, that having been said by the more cynical amongst us, high price charlatans can perform a useful function, in that the gullible may learn the lesson of discernment from their experience of being fleeced. Maybe even feel the cold wind of Reality blow around their nether regions, awaking then to a chance to take a second take on what they are doing with their Lives and the basis of their personal value systems.
"Buying" so-called experiences and tools only reduces involvement to that of the vicarious. It is only when we pay the full price of Involvement, of Hard Work and of Dedication, do the "doors of the inner temple" open to us, and then we own, by dint of our efforts, the key to Self Actualisation.
Making one’s own tools leads to a greater understanding of that they "are" and what their symbolism and uses are, as well as the limitations inherent in either the tools or in their user. They are your tools, with part of you in the making and forming of the implement. And at the same time, you too are forged in the fire of involved construction and self-development.
It is true that we do give away what we cherish as valued gifts to people whom we believe are worthy it. It is the same in Craft. Craft training was always traditionally given away free of charge.
One reason is that the people who train had gained a great deal from the Craft and they feel it is their duty to give something back. They want to ensure the future of the thing that they cherish by passing it on to people who they believe will work with it and treat it with the same respect.
To my mind, the Craft has both instrumental and non-instrumental value. It is this non-instrumental value of the Craft that leads us to cherish it. We find it undesirable that things that we cherish should be turned into moneymaking commodities. Therefore it is undesirable that the Craft is sold for hundreds of pounds in Wicca courses and is used to sell over priced new age ‘knick knacks’.
Hoswarth., J., (2007) , Neither Use Nor Ornament, (Environment, Ethics and Human Concern) , Open University
Location: Stowmarket, England
Author's Profile: To learn more about Rhys Chisnall - Click HERE
Other Articles: Rhys Chisnall has posted 17 additional articles- View them?
Other Listings: To view ALL of my listings: Click HERE
Email Rhys Chisnall... (No, I have NOT opted to receive Pagan Invites! Please do NOT send me anonymous invites to groups, sales and events.)
Web Site Content (including: text - graphics - html - look & feel)
Copyright 1997-2013 The Witches' Voice Inc. All rights reserved
Note: Authors & Artists retain the copyright for their work(s) on this website.
Unauthorized reproduction without prior permission is a violation of copyright laws.
Website structure, evolution and php coding by Fritz Jung on a Macintosh G5.
Any and all personal political opinions expressed in the public listing sections (including, but not restricted to, personals, events, groups, shops, Wrenâ€™s Nest, etc.) are solely those of the author(s) and do not reflect the opinion of The Witchesâ€™ Voice, Inc. TWV is a nonprofit, nonpartisan educational organization.
Sponsorship: Visit the Witches' Voice Sponsor Page for info on how you
can help support this Community Resource. Donations ARE Tax Deductible.
The Witches' Voice carries a 501(c)(3) certificate and a Federal Tax ID.
Mail Us: The Witches' Voice Inc., P.O. Box 341018, Tampa, Florida 33694-1018 U.S.A.
of The World
NOTE: The essay on this page contains the writings and opinions of the listed author(s) and is not necessarily shared or endorsed by the Witches' Voice inc.
The Witches' Voice does not verify or attest to the historical accuracy contained in the content of this essay.
All WitchVox essays contain a valid email address, feel free to send your comments, thoughts or concerns directly to the listed author(s).