Week of: August 4th. 2013 ...
The Deeper Meaning of Harvest Celebration
Week of: March 31st. 2013 ...
Harp! Sing For Me: Musings on a More Sustainable Future.
Week of: March 24th. 2013 ...
Women Walk to Heal the River
Week of: March 3rd. 2013 ...
Artisan Sea Salt: Organic, Traditional Healing, Medieval Re-creation, and Cleansing Magic!
Week of: December 30th. 2012 ...
Four Thieves Vinegar: History, Uses, and Recipe
Week of: October 28th. 2012 ...
Samhain: a New View
Week of: September 2nd. 2012 ...
A Pagan Chaplaincy Perspective
Week of: August 19th. 2012 ...
More Than Animals: The Totemic Ecosystem
Week of: July 22nd. 2012 ...
Thoughts Are Energy: "The Dark Knight Rises"
Week of: July 8th. 2012 ...
Spiritual Learning and Social Change
Week of: July 1st. 2012 ...
Animal Religion: a Proposal
Week of: June 24th. 2012 ...
Loving Balance: Competition and Community
Week of: April 10th. 2011 ...
Better People = Better World
Week of: October 24th. 2010 ...
Week of: September 12th. 2010 ...
Peek-A-Boo: Finding the Sacred
Week of: August 1st. 2010 ...
Compost and Natural Fertilizers: Practical Offerings to the Land
People Are Part of Nature Too
Week of: June 27th. 2010 ...
Cell Phones: A Rude Awakening
Week of: April 25th. 2010 ...
How Magic Can Save the World
The Sanctity of Ancient Hunters
Life at Lizard Holler
Week of: April 4th. 2010 ...
The Delicate Dance of Balance
Week of: March 28th. 2010 ...
Everyday Things Have Ancient Roots
Pagan Carbon Footprints
Week of: March 21st. 2010 ...
The Prayer of Transcendent Smoke
Week of: February 21st. 2010 ...
Week of: November 22nd. 2009 ...
A True Inspiration for Healing Our Planet
Week of: November 1st. 2009 ...
Week of: October 11th. 2009 ...
I Buried Maia Today
Week of: May 10th. 2009 ...
The Abuse of Parents and the Abuse of Mother Earth
Week of: March 8th. 2009 ...
Why Hug a Tree - Or To At Least Pay More Attention To One
Our Mother Crystal
Week of: December 28th. 2008 ...
Connecting To The Land
Week of: September 21st. 2008 ...
Healing Children, Healing Earth
Week of: April 27th. 2008 ...
She Needs You to Listen, Her Children...
Musings About the Land: The Turning of Spring to Summer
Week of: April 20th. 2008 ...
Baba Yaga in the Sacred Landscape--a Witch Approaches Another Earth Day
What We Can Do For The World
Week of: March 23rd. 2008 ...
Paganism is a Dirty, Dirty Word
Week of: January 20th. 2008 ...
Pagans and Environmental Issues: Can We Save the World?
"An Ye Harm None" On A Global Scale
Week of: January 6th. 2008 ...
Higher Knowledge: The Enriching and Enabling Factor
Week of: December 30th. 2007 ...
On Being a Pagan Omnivore
Week of: December 23rd. 2007 ...
A Sacred Retreat
Week of: December 2nd. 2007 ...
Saving Mother Earth from Us Nasty Humans: A Contrarian P.O.V.
'Earth Is In Trouble', So Let's Capitalize On the Trend
Week of: November 25th. 2007 ...
The Spine of the Dragon...is Love
Week of: September 9th. 2007 ...
Nature Spirits: Tree Spirits
Week of: January 21st. 2007 ...
Eco – Witch (Part I )
Week of: July 16th. 2006 ...
Think Your Paganism Isn't Nature-based? Think Again...
Week of: May 8th. 2005 ...
On Seeds and Connection
Week of: April 24th. 2005 ...
Week of: April 17th. 2005 ...
Where the Christians Go Wrong and Why the Pagans Don’t Get It
Week of: March 19th. 2004 ...
Confessions of a Dirt Worshipper
Week of: April 20th. 2003 ...
Night Vision: Where Did the Stars Go?
Week of: April 22nd. 2002 ...
Every Day is Earth Day
From the Waterfront...
Pagans and the Environment: Leaders or Laggards?
NOTE: For a complete list of articles related to this chapter... Visit the Main Index FOR this section.
Loving Balance: Competition and Community
Article ID: 15010
Age Group: Adult
Days Up: 625
Times Read: 1,423
RSS Views: 15,396
Author: Verda Smedley
Posted: June 24th. 2012
Times Viewed: 1,423
Recently I was asked to provide examples of competition in a grassland biomass and I have thought about it off and on for a while now. I could probably offer hundreds of examples, but the question itself bothered me.
Over the years I have grown to despise this type of compartmentalized thinking as well as the perception that the very notion of competition was somehow immoral or not evolved. That is certainly not the case in the natural world. We now perceive everything as stored neatly in its own little box. We view an idea such as competition as a satellite sitting alone in space rather than seeing all of Creation holistically. I wondered if such thinking was the outcome of a belief perpetuated for a long time that humanity was superior to all else, separated from the whole and viewed singularly. When confronted by something that tried to climb out its box we became miffed, wielding real or imaginary swords and making it clear, either get back in the box or else. We have displaced and slaughtered everything that did not bend to our will, plants, animals, and other people. After six, eight, maybe ten millennia of such behavior we have cultivated a new mode of thinking; that the moral high ground is to regard all displays of competition as distasteful and often outrageous.
Tears come to our eyes when we watch sea lions going after penguins or mountain lions feasting on fawns. As a species, we are clearly conflicted and confused, remaining as out of balance as we were in the days of Manifest Destiny and beyond. And even as we hold this moral high ground as the height of enlightenment we fail to view even clinically our horrendous over-population (now exceeding many times the carrying capacity of our beloved Earth) as the very trigger that spawns the most savage competition for resources. I could only conclude that the initial question was flawed and I went back to my understanding of the natural world to sort it out. I realized that I struck upon it in Ancestral Airs:
“Our conversation turned quickly to the tournaments that were to be held the next day. The games represented the sacred mandate of rivalry in natural order. All plants and animals exhibited one or more of these imperatives, driving away opponents with painful or aggressive tactics. Many birds, scavengers, and meat eaters competed fiercely with each other, as did we. It wasn’t uncommon for one to harm another in effort to protect its territory and the resources within it. From the mystery contained in the interchange was sprung the concept of community where the swing and sway of ideas and feelings, even when hostile, were held in loving balance.”
Community, that is what an ecosystem is, a community of plants and animals (including humans) that for whatever strategy might be employed, is held in loving balance. It is definitely not looking individually at two or ten plants and citing them as examples of competition. When we were Earth-worshipping Pagans we were the definitive experts of the natural world’s harmony and we lived within its dictate. We understood innately, and in detail we can only imagine now, that nature held it all in mysterious check and that is a mystery we have yet to resolve.
I don’t think we ever will, or will know again, the complex mystery of the Primordial Mother Goddess the Earth. For millions of years, bands and communities of hunter-gatherers with their incomparable genius for all things Earth succeeded in living as simply one of countless species that made up a given biomass. We didn’t stand on the sideline watching, we were an intrinsic part of it. And yet not our relatives or we made a detrimental impact on our planet, most left without a single trace of having ever been alive.
Before I spin off into too much esoteric, I want to draw your attention to the book I regard as the finest ever written about ecology and its many facets of mystery. It is called The Machinery of Nature and is written by Paul R. Ehrlich. If you never read another you must read this one. He concludes, after explaining the laws of energy conservation, that “In any ecosystem the amount of energy available to each successive trophic level declines. Thus more energy is available to support plants than herbivores, more to support herbivores than carnivores, and so on.”
He goes on to explain “that the biomass of grasses and other grazed plants is much greater than that of the grazers, and that the biomass of the grazers is much greater than that of the predators that attack them.” He further states, “About 10% of the energy that flows into one trophic level is available to the next. Thus if green plants in an area manage to capture 10, 000 units of energy from the sun, only about 1000 units will be available to support herbivores, and only about 100 to support carnivores.” Too bad my inquisitor never read this book. Clearly, no two species competes with each other, not really. Each, plant, animal, or we, competes for needed units of energy to survive; we compete for sunlight.
Here, Ehrlich has made an absolutely eloquent case for feeding our ventricose population with plants. But even more intriguing is the fact that this is supported by the study of Paleo diets, a study decades old for me. It has been implied for centuries that our Stone Age ancestors were big meat eaters. That is a myth. Granted, our big, fat brains need a steady supply of protein, but all of the evidence points to the fact that we as humans (and our relatives) are and always have been omnivores where at least 85% of our diets were made up of vegetable matter. Statistically as Ehrlich points out, and esoterically with my insistence of hunter-gatherer genius of the world in which he lived, being a big meat eater is both impractical and probably impossible. But how might this have led to the concept of community?
In the idealistic hunter-gatherer world, population grew and declined based on the availability of food. The only way to protect what was then a fragile and fleeting population was to share equally all available resources. We held a cultivated view that in doing so reproductive imperatives insured the survival and longevity of the tribe via future generations. Over harvesting and over hunting stood in stark contrast to that and we knew it. Frugality quickly became the foundation of a community’s ability to endure and led to a level of Earth worship and mystical knowledge unlike anything we have seen since. Yes, we competed with every organism in the biomass but our wisdom prevented us from driving any species into extinction. We understood in intimate detail the loss of any species led to starvation.
In contrast to that -- and no doubt due to our notion of human superiority and our over-population -- we have been driven to compete for every scrap, every inch of soil, every glimpse of attention for which our fragile egos hunger. Any hunter-gatherer from any place or time would immediately recognize how profoundly out of balance his descendants have become.
Technology is now paraded as the measure of civilized society, the litmus test of evolution, even as civilization remains defined by the quality and care it extends to its community. As a species that same technology has driven each of us into our own individual bubbles of isolation even as we celebrate those technological breakthroughs. When once long ago our community held precedence over personal ambition and identity we are left with the identity of one and utterly alone even as our glutted population increases minute by minute. We are rutting out an existence devoid of companionship or sense of purpose, competing fiercely and failing miserably. No wonder competition as one of the sacred mandates of healthy ecosystems has gotten such a bad rap.
If we really want to catch the prayers of our shamanic ancestors, the true magic makers of our species, we must first step into the harmonic balance of community found in knowing the natural world. In principle at least we can take that wisdom and rebuild our sense of community in profoundly simple ways. When we have the resources to buy two heads of lettuce, give one away to our neighbor. When our gardens are particularly productive, we can donate the surplus to our local food bank. We can donate time to feed the homeless or help our neighbor solve his problem, whatever that problem might be. There was a time when we continually assessed the needs of our community and took action to insure that all survived, and survived well. We now careen off into a lonely, virtual world that neither feeds our bodies, our souls, our neighbors, nor fuels a sense of mystery and wonder.
And while we struggle to relinquish our notion of me, myself, and I, lets remember all those elders imprisoned and forgotten in facilities. They are our last link to comprehend our misguided path. Once revered as the wisdom keepers, we now view our elders with a shrug and a sigh. They and they alone can tell us their piece of the puzzle and show us where our missteps might have happened. Our elders who remain alive today have the long view and have marked the long calendar. With their help we can retrace our steps back to the shamanic view of community, founded in natural order and its sacred mandates, where everything is held in loving balance.
The Machinery of Nature by Paul R. Ehrlich
Copyright: I hold the copyright for all of my work.
Location: Santa Fe, New Mexico
Author's Profile: To learn more about Verda Smedley - Click HERE
Other Articles: Verda Smedley has posted 16 additional articles- View them?
Other Listings: To view ALL of my listings: Click HERE
Email Verda Smedley... (Yes! I have opted to receive invites to Pagan events, groups, and commercial sales)
Web Site Content (including: text - graphics - html - look & feel)
Copyright 1997-2014 The Witches' Voice Inc. All rights reserved
Note: Authors & Artists retain the copyright for their work(s) on this website.
Unauthorized reproduction without prior permission is a violation of copyright laws.
Website structure, evolution and php coding by Fritz Jung on a Macintosh G5.
Any and all personal political opinions expressed in the public listing sections (including, but not restricted to, personals, events, groups, shops, Wrenâ€™s Nest, etc.) are solely those of the author(s) and do not reflect the opinion of The Witchesâ€™ Voice, Inc. TWV is a nonprofit, nonpartisan educational organization.
Sponsorship: Visit the Witches' Voice Sponsor Page for info on how you
can help support this Community Resource. Donations ARE Tax Deductible.
The Witches' Voice carries a 501(c)(3) certificate and a Federal Tax ID.
Mail Us: The Witches' Voice Inc., P.O. Box 341018, Tampa, Florida 33694-1018 U.S.A.
of The World
NOTE: The essay on this page contains the writings and opinions of the listed author(s) and is not necessarily shared or endorsed by the Witches' Voice inc.
The Witches' Voice does not verify or attest to the historical accuracy contained in the content of this essay.
All WitchVox essays contain a valid email address, feel free to send your comments, thoughts or concerns directly to the listed author(s).